My Newest Siggy...
tested something, so please, rate it...
i know, it looks a bit Plain, but...
It's not that your getting worse, your trying WAY "too" MUCH, at once. There's way too much stuff going on, look at my Sig, take a look at Heather's first sig([F]Battery). Your going extreme, and that's what make them bad.
Your text is terrible(sorry to put it that way). Try and keep text straight to the point, or to a minimum.
The way your text is being "popping out" doesn't necessarily make it look better, it makes it look terrible.
Your best 2 sigs, out of the 4 I can see, is the one with Shadow Fang, and the one I have quoted. The other 2 are just terrible thanks to text. And the 2 I say are the best, are in the bad, again text.
Now, I'm going to middle one in the text, I understand you want Gunz rendered into your sigs, but it's tough to have them in a good spot. The middle one, would look fucking awesome without the text, and that Gunz render.
Lastly, to the bottom sig that you have in your signature. The Render on the far-left would look perfect in the middle without the overlay/glow on the outside of him, and the text should be removed, and the other 2 renders should be removed. The background is amazing.
If you'd like more critique, feel free to post ALL of your sigs.
Also, Sorry for some of the swearing, it's for "stressing" the point I'm trying to make.